Closed Sets & Limit Points

Open sets are the raw material of a topology. Closed sets are their mirror image, and they're the natural language for limits: a closed set is one you can't escape by taking limits. This page also builds the closure and interior of a set, and gets our first look at convergence without distances.

Closed Sets

The definition is short, and it's defined entirely in terms of open sets.

Let $(X, \mathcal{T})$ be a topological space. A subset $A \subset X$ is said to be closed if the set $X \setminus A$ is open in $X$.

The word "closed" makes it sound like the opposite of "open." It isn't.

Sets are not doors. A set can be open, closed, both, or neither, and $\mathbb{R}$ is somehow both. Whoever named these was not thinking about doors.

In $\mathbb{R}$, which of $[0, 1]$, $(0, 1)$, $[0, 1)$, and $\mathbb{R}$ are closed?


$[0, 1]$ is closed: its complement $(-\infty, 0) \cup (1, \infty)$ is open. $(0, 1)$ is not closed: its complement $(-\infty, 0] \cup [1, \infty)$ has no room around $0$. $[0, 1)$ is not closed for the same reason at $1$ (and it isn't open either). $\mathbb{R}$ is closed because its complement $\emptyset$ is open, and $\mathbb{R}$ is also open.

Taking complements turns the three axioms for open sets into three facts about closed sets. Unions and intersections swap roles.

Let $(X, \mathcal{T})$ be a topological space. Then:

  1. $\emptyset$ and $X$ are closed;
  2. arbitrary intersections of closed sets are closed;
  3. finite unions of closed sets are closed.
Show proof

Proof. (1) $\emptyset$ and $X$ are closed because their complements, $X$ and $\emptyset$, are open.

(2) Given a collection of closed sets $\{D_\alpha\}_{\alpha \in J}$, De Morgan's law gives $$X \setminus \bigcap_{\alpha \in J} D_\alpha = \bigcup_{\alpha \in J} (X \setminus D_\alpha).$$ Each $X \setminus D_\alpha$ is open, so the right side is a union of open sets, which is open. Hence $\bigcap_\alpha D_\alpha$ is closed.

(3) If $E_1, \dots, E_n$ are closed, De Morgan's law gives $$X \setminus \bigcup_{i=1}^{n} E_i = \bigcap_{i=1}^{n} (X \setminus E_i),$$ a finite intersection of open sets, which is open. Hence $\bigcup_{i=1}^n E_i$ is closed. $\blacksquare$

Sort some subsets of $\mathbb{R}$ before going on. The explanations for each card use ideas from later in the page (accumulation points), so come back after reading if one doesn't make sense yet.

Open, Closed, Both, Neither

In a subspace, closed sets come from cutting down closed sets of the big space, exactly like open sets did.

Let $Y$ be a subspace of $X$. Then a set $A$ is closed in $Y$ if and only if it equals the intersection of a closed set of $X$ with $Y$.

Show proof

Proof. Assume $A = D \cap Y$, where $D$ is closed in $X$. Then $X \setminus D$ is open in $X$, so $(X \setminus D) \cap Y$ is open in $Y$. But $(X \setminus D) \cap Y = Y \setminus A$. So $Y \setminus A$ is open in $Y$, and $A$ is closed in $Y$.

Conversely, assume $A$ is closed in $Y$. Then $Y \setminus A$ is open in $Y$, so there is an open set $U$ of $X$ with $Y \setminus A = U \cap Y$. The set $X \setminus U$ is closed in $X$, and $A = Y \cap (X \setminus U)$. $\blacksquare$

Same move as on the Subspace Topology page, where open sets of $Y$ were open sets of $X$ cut down to $Y$. Now closed sets work the same way.

Let $Y = [0, 1] \cup (2, 3)$, a subspace of $\mathbb{R}$. Is $[0, 1]$ open in $Y$? Closed in $Y$?


Both. $[0, 1] = Y \cap (-1, \frac{3}{2})$, so it is open in $Y$. And $[0, 1] = Y \cap [0, 1]$ with $[0, 1]$ closed in $\mathbb{R}$, so it is closed in $Y$. (Likewise $(2, 3)$ is both open and closed in $Y$.) A space that splits into two such pieces is called disconnected.

That "both open and closed" piece is exactly what the Connected Spaces page is built on. A space is connected when the only such sets are $\emptyset$ and the whole space.

Interior and Closure

Every set sits between a largest open set inside it and a smallest closed set around it.

Let $(X, \mathcal{T})$ be a topological space and $A \subset X$. The interior of $A$, denoted $\operatorname{int}(A)$, is the union of all open sets contained in $A$.

A union of open sets is open, so $\operatorname{int}(A)$ is the largest open set inside $A$. Flip everything for the closure.

Let $(X, \mathcal{T})$ be a topological space and $A \subset X$. The closure of $A$, denoted $\overline{A}$, is the intersection of all closed sets containing $A$.

An intersection of closed sets is closed, so $\overline{A}$ is the smallest closed set containing $A$. In particular, $A$ is closed if and only if $A = \overline{A}$. Two small definitions make closures much easier to compute.

Let $A$ and $B$ be arbitrary sets. We say $A$ intersects $B$ if $A \cap B \neq \emptyset$.

And a convenient word for "an open set around a point."

The set $U$ is a neighborhood of $x$ if $U$ is an open set containing $x$.

Now the closure can be tested one point at a time.

Let $(X, \mathcal{T})$ be a topological space, $A \subset X$, and let $\mathcal{B}$ be a basis for $\mathcal{T}$. Then:

  1. $x \in \overline{A}$ if and only if every neighborhood of $x$ intersects $A$;
  2. $x \in \overline{A}$ if and only if every basis element $B \in \mathcal{B}$ containing $x$ intersects $A$.
Show proof

Proof. (1) We prove the contrapositive in both directions. If $x \notin \overline{A}$, then $U = X \setminus \overline{A}$ is open (since $\overline{A}$ is closed) and is a neighborhood of $x$ that does not intersect $A$. Conversely, if some neighborhood $V$ of $x$ does not intersect $A$, then $X \setminus V$ is a closed set containing $A$, so by definition $\overline{A} \subset X \setminus V$. Hence $x \notin \overline{A}$.

(2) If every neighborhood of $x$ intersects $A$, then so does every basis element containing $x$, because basis elements are open. Conversely, suppose every basis element containing $x$ intersects $A$, and let $U$ be any neighborhood of $x$. There is $B \in \mathcal{B}$ with $x \in B \subset U$, and $B$ intersects $A$, so $U$ does too. $\blacksquare$

Here's the theorem in action on the real line.

In $\mathbb{R}$, find the closures of $(0, 1]$, $K = \{\frac{1}{n} : n \in \mathbb{Z}_+\}$, and $\mathbb{Q}$, and the interior of $\mathbb{Q}$.


$\overline{(0, 1]} = [0, 1]$: every interval around $0$ contains small positive numbers, and any point outside $[0, 1]$ has an interval around it missing $(0, 1]$.

$\overline{K} = K \cup \{0\}$: every interval $(-\varepsilon, \varepsilon)$ contains $\frac{1}{n}$ once $n > \frac{1}{\varepsilon}$, and every other point outside $K$ has an interval around it that misses $K$.

$\overline{\mathbb{Q}} = \mathbb{R}$, because every open interval contains a rational. And $\operatorname{int}(\mathbb{Q}) = \emptyset$, because every open interval contains an irrational.

Accumulation Points

The closure adds exactly the points that $A$ crowds up against. To make that precise, we want points where $A$ comes arbitrarily close without counting the point itself.

Let $(X, \mathcal{T})$ be a topological space, $A \subset X$, and $x \in X$. Then $x$ is an accumulation point of $A$ (also called a limit point) if every neighborhood of $x$ intersects $A$ in some point other than $x$ itself. Equivalently, $x \in \overline{A \setminus \{x\}}$.

The collection of all of them gets a symbol.

Let $(X, \mathcal{T})$ be a topological space and $A \subset X$. The set of all accumulation points of $A$ is called the derived set of $A$, denoted $A'$.

An accumulation point doesn't have to be in $A$ (like $0$ for $K$), and a point of $A$ doesn't have to be an accumulation point (like $\frac{1}{2}$ for $K$, which has a neighborhood containing no other point of $K$). Drag the point and its neighborhood around and watch the three sets.

What Kind of Point?

In every preset, the red band was the purple set plus the green band. That's the theorem.

Let $(X, \mathcal{T})$ be a topological space and $A \subset X$. Then $$\overline{A} = A \cup A'.$$

Proof. Clearly $A \subset \overline{A}$. If $x \in A'$, then every neighborhood of $x$ intersects $A$, so $x \in \overline{A}$ by the previous theorem. Hence $A \cup A' \subset \overline{A}$. For the reverse inclusion, let $x \in \overline{A}$. If $x \in A$, we're done. If $x \notin A$, then every neighborhood of $x$ intersects $A$ (previous theorem), and since $x \notin A$, the intersection must happen at a point other than $x$. So $x \in A'$. Therefore $\overline{A} = A \cup A'$. $\blacksquare$

And this gives the most useful test for closedness.

A subset of a topological space is closed if and only if it contains all of its limit points.

Proof. The set $A$ is closed if and only if $A = \overline{A} = A \cup A'$, and $A \cup A' = A$ exactly when $A' \subset A$. $\blacksquare$

When you want to show a set is closed, you have two strategies: show the complement is open, or show the set contains all its limit points. Pick whichever is easier. For $K \cup \{0\}$, the limit-point route is a one-liner (its only limit point is $0$), while the complement route needs infinitely many intervals.

Convergence

Sequences make sense in any topological space: replace "within $\varepsilon$" by "inside a neighborhood."

In an arbitrary topological space $X$, a sequence $x_1, x_2, \dots$ of points of $X$ converges to the point $x \in X$ provided that, corresponding to each neighborhood $U$ of $x$, there exists a positive integer $N$ such that $x_n \in U$ for all $n \ge N$.

In $\mathbb{R}$ this is the calculus definition, since the neighborhoods $(x - \varepsilon, x + \varepsilon)$ are enough to check. In stranger topologies, strange things happen.

In the finite complement topology, $\frac{1}{n}$ converges to $0$. And to $\pi$. And to $-7$. Exercise 4 below proves it.

The fix for limits that aren't unique is the Hausdorff condition. In a Hausdorff space every sequence has at most one limit.

Exercises

The first two use the theorems about subspaces and products.

Show that if $D$ is closed in $E$ and $E$ is closed in $X$, then $D$ is closed in $X$.

Show proof

Proof. Since $E \subset X$ is a subspace and $D$ is closed in $E$, the theorem on closed sets of subspaces gives a closed set $F \subset X$ with $D = E \cap F$. Since $E$ is also closed in $X$, $D$ is an intersection of two closed sets of $X$, so it is closed in $X$. $\blacksquare$

For the next one, draw the picture in $\mathbb{R}^2$ first.

Show that if $D$ is closed in $X$ and $E$ is closed in $Y$, then $D \times E$ is closed in $X \times Y$.

Show proof

Proof. A point $(x, y)$ is outside $D \times E$ exactly when $x \notin D$ or $y \notin E$, so $$(X \times Y) \setminus (D \times E) = \big((X \setminus D) \times Y\big) \cup \big(X \times (Y \setminus E)\big).$$ Since $D$ and $E$ are closed, $X \setminus D$ and $Y \setminus E$ are open, so $(X \setminus D) \times Y$ and $X \times (Y \setminus E)$ are products of open sets, which are open in $X \times Y$. Their union is open, so $D \times E$ is closed. $\blacksquare$

A quick computation in a strange topology.

In the finite complement topology on $\mathbb{R}$, to what point or points does the sequence $x_n = \frac{1}{n}$ converge?

Show answer

To every point of $\mathbb{R}$. Let $y \in \mathbb{R}$ and let $V$ be a neighborhood of $y$ in $(\mathbb{R}, \mathcal{T}_f)$. Then $\mathbb{R} \setminus V$ is finite. Since the terms $x_n = \frac{1}{n}$ are all distinct, only finitely many of them can lie in the finite set $\mathbb{R} \setminus V$, so there is $N$ with $x_n \in V$ for all $n \ge N$. Hence $x_n \to y$. Since $y$ was arbitrary, the sequence converges to every point of $\mathbb{R}$.

Three facts about closures that you'll use constantly.

Let $A$, $B$, and $A_\alpha$ denote subsets of $X$. Prove the following:

  1. If $A \subset B$, then $\overline{A} \subset \overline{B}$.
  2. $\overline{A \cup B} = \overline{A} \cup \overline{B}$.
  3. $\bigcup \overline{A_\alpha} \subset \overline{\bigcup A_\alpha}$; give an example where equality fails.
Show proof

(a) Let $x \in \overline{A}$ and let $U$ be a neighborhood of $x$. Then $U \cap A \neq \emptyset$, and $A \subset B$, so $U \cap B \neq \emptyset$. Every neighborhood of $x$ intersects $B$, so $x \in \overline{B}$.

(b) Since $A \subset A \cup B$ and $B \subset A \cup B$, part (a) gives $\overline{A} \cup \overline{B} \subset \overline{A \cup B}$. Now suppose $x \notin \overline{A} \cup \overline{B}$. Then there are neighborhoods $U$ and $V$ of $x$ with $U \cap A = \emptyset$ and $V \cap B = \emptyset$. So $U \cap V$ is a neighborhood of $x$ with $(U \cap V) \cap (A \cup B) = \emptyset$, and $x \notin \overline{A \cup B}$. Hence $\overline{A \cup B} = \overline{A} \cup \overline{B}$.

(c) For each $\beta$, $A_\beta \subset \bigcup_\alpha A_\alpha$, so by part (a), $\overline{A_\beta} \subset \overline{\bigcup_\alpha A_\alpha}$. Taking the union over $\beta$ gives the inclusion. For a counterexample, let $\mathbb{Q} = \{q_1, q_2, \dots\}$ be a listing of the rationals in $\mathbb{R}$ and $A_n = \{q_n\}$. Each one-point set is closed, so $$\bigcup_{n=1}^{\infty} \overline{\{q_n\}} = \mathbb{Q}, \quad \text{but} \quad \overline{\bigcup_{n=1}^{\infty} \{q_n\}} = \overline{\mathbb{Q}} = \mathbb{R}. \; \blacksquare$$

Part (b) only works for finitely many sets, which is what part (c) is warning you about.

"The closure of a union is the union of the closures" is true for two sets (so for finitely many) and false for infinitely many. Same pattern as closed sets themselves: finite unions are safe, infinite ones are not.

Spicy Bonus

This one is a real prelim problem. It describes a space built as an increasing union of pieces, where "open" is decided piece by piece.

🌶️ SPICY BONUS 🌶️

Let $X$ be a topological space and let $X_1 \subset X_2 \subset X_3 \subset \dots$ be a nested sequence of subsets of $X$ such that $$X = \bigcup_{n=1}^{\infty} X_n.$$ Suppose that every $X_n$ has the subspace topology, and that a subset $U \subset X$ is open in $X$ if and only if $U \cap X_n$ is open in $X_n$ for all $n \in \mathbb{N}$. Suppose that every singleton in $X_n$ is closed in $X_n$, for all $n$. Let $A \subset X$, and suppose $A \cap X_n$ is a finite set for all $n \in \mathbb{N}$. Prove that $A$ is closed in $X$.

Show proof

Proof. Fix $n$. The set $A \cap X_n$ is a finite union of singletons, each closed in $X_n$, so $A \cap X_n$ is closed in $X_n$ (finite unions of closed sets are closed). Therefore $$(X \setminus A) \cap X_n = X_n \setminus (A \cap X_n)$$ is open in $X_n$. This holds for every $n$, so by the hypothesis on $X$, the set $X \setminus A$ is open in $X$. Hence $A$ is closed in $X$. $\blacksquare$